Recycler Step Can vs Dual Compartment Slim Open Can: Which Recycling Bin Fits Your Home?

If you're serious about recycling at home, you've probably noticed that not all bins are created equal. The two most popular styles from simplehuman — the recycler step can and the dual compartment slim open can — each solve the sorting problem differently, but which one is right for your kitchen? I've spent time testing both, and the answer depends on your space, how much waste you generate, and whether you prefer a foot pedal or a hands-free open top.

In this comparison, I'll walk you through the key differences in design, capacity, and everyday use so you can choose the recycling bin that actually makes sorting easier — not just another chore.

Design and Footprint: Step Can vs Open Can

The recycler step can is a classic step-on design with a lid that lifts when you press the pedal. It's typically taller and narrower, with a built-in divider that splits the interior into two compartments — one for recyclables, one for trash or compost. This makes it a true all-in-one solution for kitchens where floor space is tight. The lid keeps odors contained and hides the contents, which is nice if your bin sits in a visible spot.

On the other hand, the dual compartment slim open can, like the 20L Dual Compartment Slim Open Can, Brushed, has no lid. It's an open-top bin with two separate chambers side by side, each about 10 liters. The slim profile (just 20 inches wide) lets it slide into narrow gaps between cabinets or next to a fridge. Because there's no lid, you can toss items in quickly without touching anything — great for high-traffic kitchens. The tradeoff? No odor control and a more exposed look.

• Measure your available width: step cans need about 12–16 inches of floor space; slim open cans need about 20 inches but can fit in tighter spots if placed sideways.

Sorting Capacity and Practical Use

The recycler step can typically holds between 30 and 50 liters total, split into two compartments. That's enough for a small to medium household's daily recyclables and trash. The step pedal lets you open both compartments at once or just one side, which is handy when your hands are full. However, the divided interior means each side is smaller than a dedicated single bin — if you generate a lot of one type of waste, you might find yourself emptying it more often.

The dual compartment slim open can gives you two separate 10-liter bins in one sleek unit. Because there's no lid, you can easily fit larger items like cereal boxes or milk jugs without jamming them under a lid. The open design also makes it simpler to line each side with a bag — just drop in a standard kitchen bag. But without a foot pedal, you'll have to bend down to access the bins, and the open top means odors (from food scraps or dirty recyclables) can escape more easily.

• For households that rinse recyclables, the open can is easier to load; for those who prefer a neat, concealed look, the step can wins.

Which One Should You Choose?

Pick the recycler step can if you want a single unit that hides waste, controls odors, and lets you sort with a foot pedal. It's ideal for kitchens where the bin is visible and you prefer a tidy appearance. Just be aware that the compartments are smaller, so you'll empty them more often if you recycle heavily.

Go with the dual compartment slim open can if you have a narrow space and want maximum accessibility. The 20L Dual Compartment Slim Open Can, Brushed is a great example — it fits in tight spots and makes tossing recyclables effortless. It's also easier to clean since there's no lid mechanism. The main downside is the lack of odor control and the open look, so it works best in a more utilitarian area like a mudroom or a kitchen corner where you don't mind seeing the contents.

• If you're still torn, consider a hybrid approach: use a step can for trash and a slim open can for recyclables only — that way you get the best of both worlds.

Both the recycler step can and the dual compartment slim open can are excellent recycling bins, but they serve different priorities. The step can offers concealment and odor control with a pedal, while the open can prioritizes accessibility and a slim footprint. Measure your space, think about your waste volume, and choose the one that fits your daily routine — not just your countertop.